Petee’s Pie Company

Reviews

• Carl B.

  star star star star star 17 July 2026

  Problem: We were celebrating my dad's birthday the next day. He loves cherry pie. I couldn't find a good one.
  
  Solution: My brilliant friend suggested Petee's, which has a sour cherry pie.
  
  Problem: Their delivery window fell in the middle of my work day.
  
  Solution: They deliver far from their store! $15 flat.
  
  Problem: Right after ordering I realized, flat delivery fee means, order more pie!
  
  Solution: After a little back and forth, they added to my order and invoiced me for four mini-pies (Salty Chocolate Chess, Lemon Poppyseed Chess, Brown Butter Honey Pecan, Coconut Custard)
  
  Problem: None.
  
  Solution: Five sweet, salty, delicious pies.
  
  Hard to pick a favorite. Pecan always starts with a big lead for me, but they were all fantastic, crust and filling. My dad loved the cherry filling. As usual, he skipped much of the crust. Solution: My mom ate it.

• Howard P.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 17 July 2026

  Tonight I strolled in after nearly walking about excited to get a slice of pie.
  I ordered a slice of Wild Blueberry Pie, and had the counter person put it to go. I was pleasant even if the person was slow to attend to me. He went to the back and was chatting w/a co-worker and placed the slice on a box to go. It was over $6.50 for the slice. Pricey!
  So, long story short, I got home and as I opened the box I found the smallest slice I d ever seen.
  To say the least I was really disappointed to pay so much for so little and w/slow service to boot.
  I'll
  Never go here again nor would I recommend you do so.
  Too pricey and for too little. Better to go to While Foods to get a whole pie for the slice of two here at this far overrated place.

• Melanie R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 10 July 2026

  I was so excited to return after my last experience. I came on a Sunday afternoon and got a key lime pie. This was probably the WORSE key lime pie I ever had in my life. The consistency was watery. It wasn't as tart in flavor but very eggy. The cream on top tasted like it's been sitting in the fridge for a long time and the crust was stale.
  
  After a couple more bites in, I realized the pie might have gone rancid. I felt sick and too grossed out to finish.

• Joyce C.

  star star star star star 8 July 2026

  Interior--once i walked it, the smell of deliciousness caught me off guard!! Love it haha. There's not much seating area though since most of the place was taken up as the kitchen/bakery.
  
  Service--service was great!! Very friendly staff and they tried their best to accommodate everyone's need even when they were busy.
  
  Taste--definitely recommend the banana cream, so so tasty and not at all heavy. If you're a banana fan, this would be the perfect dessert. The cheesecake was alright, but since this place specializes in pie, I would just recommend getting pies.
  
  It's about $6 a piece which was a bit pricy to me, the slice wasn't too big, but a great experience to just chill with friends and grab something different for desserts rather than ice cream for once haha.

• Ron J.

  star star star star star 5 July 2026

  I'm not a huge pie person but their slice cream is what desserts are all about. I've been coming here for sometime now and I have never just gotten a pie. I would highly recommend getting their slice cream. One time I even got the banana cream pie with their homemade ice cream "slice cream" and it was out of this world. If you're into pies. This is the place for you.
  
  Staff is really nice too. They are always welcoming and help with making tough choices.